Agency Giants
Welcome to Agency Giants, the podcast that delves into the minds of the world's top 1% agency owners. Join us as we explore the secrets behind their remarkable success and gain invaluable insights from their unique journeys.
Hosted by Jordan Platten, an industry-leading UK Youtuber and agency owner who has generated over $100 million in return on investment for a diverse variety of brands around the globe.
Each episode of the podcast features in-depth conversations with visionary agency owners who have achieved unparalleled heights in their respective fields. From digital marketing to advertising, branding to PR, we cover a diverse range of agency specialties, ensuring a wealth of knowledge and inspiration for all listeners.
Through engaging discussions, we uncover the strategies, philosophies, and innovative approaches that set these exceptional entrepreneurs apart. How did they overcome obstacles and build their agencies from the ground up? What bold decisions propelled their growth? What lessons did they learn along the way? Find out as we delve into their triumphs, failures, and everything in between.
The Agency Giants podcast goes beyond surface-level success stories. We explore the nuances of scaling agencies, managing teams, nurturing client relationships, and staying ahead of industry trends. Whether you're an aspiring agency owner, a seasoned professional seeking fresh perspectives, or simply curious about the inner workings of top-performing agencies, this podcast offers the actionable insights you crave.
Join us on this captivating journey as we unlock the strategies that drive the world's most successful agencies. Discover firsthand how these extraordinary leaders are shaping the future of the industry and learn how you can apply their wisdom to your own entrepreneurial endeavors.
If you're ready to challenge the status quo and gain a competitive edge in the world of agencies, subscribe to Agency Giants and prepare to be inspired. Get ready to unleash your potential, elevate your business acumen, and unlock the secrets to agency success with the remarkable individuals who are reshaping the industry, one groundbreaking idea at a time.
So, whether you're commuting, working out, or enjoying a moment of quiet reflection, tune in to Agency Giants and immerse yourself in the captivating stories of those who have conquered the world of agencies and are ready to share their invaluable insights with you.
Agency Giants
How We Built a 150-Person Agency With ZERO Cold Outreach | Andy Nairn | #42
The Agency Giants Podcast - Episode 42 (Andy Nairn)
__________________________________________
They started an agency with zero clients. On purpose.
Then they turned down a huge account. No pitch needed.
A few years later, Amazon handed them the Super Bowl.
Lucky Generals became the first British agency ever to win the public vote for best ad at the Super Bowl.
I asked co-founder Andy Nairn how.
His answer wasn’t what I expected.
And the best new business move they ever made? It wasn’t outbound, or ads.
It was something most agency owners would never think of.
Andy's LinkedIn: https://www.linkedin.com/in/andy-nairn-0a03396
Lucky Generals: https://luckygenerals.com/
__________________________________________
https://www.youtube.com/playlist?list=PLdO5xp5occOyeEZ2GCD21gqDKLz8Z8-Ak
__________________________________________
🎧 Stream on your favorite audio platform:
Apple Podcasts: https://podcasts.apple.com/us/podcast/the-agency-podcast/id1755717870
Spotify: https://open.spotify.com/show/0jmr989Mkl4EJQ6AyAzJfE
Amazon Music: https://music.amazon.com/podcasts/64e31809-88d4-43a3-b2e3-e59caf73aec4/the-agency-podcast
__________________________________________
Follow us on all platforms:
Instagram: https://www.instagram.com/agencygiantspodcast/
Facebook: https://www.facebook.com/agencygiantspodcast/
TikTok: https://www.tiktok.com/@agencygiants
__________________________________________
00:00 How a Small London Agency Landed the Super Bowl
02:24 From Studying Law to Chief Strategy Officer: Andy’s Path
11:14 A Failed Merger & the Birth of Lucky Generals
17:34 Winning Clients Without Outbound: PR, Saying No & Writing a Book
27:05 Founder Partnerships & Selling a Stake to Omnicom
34:20 Scaling to 150 People Without Losing the Culture
41:14 Opening in New York & UK vs US Marketing Culture
47:06 Protecting Creativity at Scale & Where AI Fits In
52:31 Virgin Atlantic, Pitching With Conviction & Turning Clients Down
You have since scaled to over 150 team members now. You completed four Super Bowl campaigns for Amazon and actually were the first British agency to ever win the public vote of best ad at the Super Bowl.
SPEAKER_01It's pretty mental that tiny little agency by global standards get a brief in the first place to do the Super Bowl spot for Amazon.
SPEAKER_00What does early stage client acquisition look like?
SPEAKER_01We deliberately decided to start with no clients, which is kind of unheard of in the ad industry. You know, we couldn't pay ourselves any money for the first few months. You have to hit the ground running. So that's what we did.
SPEAKER_00What are the three most effective strategies that you guys use in order to get yourself out there in the world?
SPEAKER_01Do great work. That's the best strategy. The best thing we ever did was write a book. All of a sudden, the dynamic complete flips. Rather than you chasing people down and sending people LinkedIn messages, that's people going to Amazon or Waterstones and buying you a book and then asking you, can you come and do a talk about it?
SPEAKER_00If you were starting an agency from scratch in the market today, what would you do differently? Maybe. Andy, welcome to Agency Giants. Yeah, thank you. Thanks for having me on. So Lucky Generals has won countless awards. You completed four Super Bowl campaigns for Amazon and actually were the first British agency to ever win the public vote of best ad at the Super Bowl, which is a big thing over in the States. I'm interested in what separates you guys from the many other great agencies that exist out there when it comes to creating good creative.
SPEAKER_01Yeah, well, I mean I think that that episode itself is kind of telling. It's it's I think it probably speaks to our fearlessness. Because if you think about it, it's pretty mental that a tiny little agency by global standards, certainly back then, by the way, would get a brief in the first place to do the Super Bowl uh spot uh for Amazon. You know, we're a little agency in Exworth Market in London. What do we know about American football? But actually, no, we backed ourselves and I thought, yeah, we can do that. Why not? We can do that, we can blag it a lot. But and actually, sometimes having that confidence and fearlessness and ability to back yourself is a huge part of running a startup and a big part in creativity, isn't it? It's what makes you take risks and feel comfortable taking risks. Uh so I think that's been part of a success, just an absolute belief that we can do things and that we're going to stretch ourselves. And if it feels a bit scary or uncomfortable, then that's actually good.
SPEAKER_00I'd like to unpack how that came about, but we'll kind of segue for now and just regress somewhat to your early stage because you you actually started off studying law, didn't you, in Edinburgh? And an early career in law. And so I'm I'm so interested in how you then pivoted from that into advertising.
SPEAKER_01Yeah, I mean I never practiced law, but I studied law, and I really loved law. I mean, it's an amazing, interesting subject, and I have lots of friends now who are lawyers who, you know, from those days who uh are really interesting, sort of eclectically minded people. Um but I I got steered in a different direction by my professor. I had this amazing, charismatic professor, such a lovely man, who when I was talking about what I liked about law and telling really what law is is putting the best case forward for you know a client, I guess. It's telling a story of a sort. And he said, Well, if you like all that kind of stuff but you want to do it in a more creative environment, maybe um you should chat to my friend who works in advertising. Um and I thought, all right, okay, I'll give it a go. And and after that, I I became absolutely intoxicated by what that might mean. And the funny thing is that that guy, that professor, uh went on to take his own advice because he then quit law uh and he became uh one of the best-selling authors in the world. There's a guy called um Alexander McCall Smith. So he sold like 60 million books around the world and is now you know celebrated all over the place for his detective novels. Uh so yeah, I think um law was a great background to uh in terms of getting you to uh practice your critical thinking um skills and is as I say it's a form of storytelling.
SPEAKER_00That's interesting. So you would say that your early creativity came from your experience in law?
SPEAKER_01Yeah, I think I think so. I don't think it's incompatible. At first I thought it was incompatible, I thought law was going to be you know perhaps a bit too corporate, but now actually the more I've taken time to reflect on that, I realised that you know the best lawyers are are really interesting people. It's not about um the application of the rules, really always. You know, it it's about finding interesting ways to get around the rules or to uh uh to interpret the rules or to not even go near the rules um at all. I mean a lot of great lawyers encourage you not to go to court, not to use the law, come up with a more lateral solution instead. And so I yeah, I I find law really fascinating, it's intellectual sort of pursuit, but but I'm really, really glad that I ended up uh taking that career um turn.
SPEAKER_00You what was the first entry point into advertising then coming out of law?
SPEAKER_01Well I had that lucky break first and then I stumbled into uh the advertising model really because I I I did what everyone did back then. Um you know, there was a slightly more formal graduate scheme that um I applied to all the big agencies. And I applied really to be an account handler because that was the only job that I had heard of or that was on any of the graduate forums. I didn't know there was a thing called planning or strategy or anything like that. Uh and then during the process, I I thankfully again someone spotted that I'd probably be absolutely shit at that and sort of steered me in another direction. So I think I've been very fortunate to have people steering me at various points. Early on in my career, from day one, I was steered to be a brand strategist or as a planner, uh, which is really unusual. Most people start off as an account handler and then um go onto planners. Maybe my account handling skills were so bad that they thought he can't even do a day of work in that department. He has to start off as a brand strategist.
SPEAKER_00So then you worked your way through multiple different agencies, ended up as the chief strategy officer at MCBD.
SPEAKER_01Yeah.
SPEAKER_00What does that chief strategy officer role look like?
SPEAKER_01The chief strategy officer role is is it's actually quite a big step up, and it's important to sort of grasp that. So you you plan all your, you know, you do strategy, you do the planning for other people's brands uh through your career, and you hopefully get to a stage where you're good at it, that's where you get recognized for it. But the then the chief strategy officer is then still maintaining that role on key clients usually and setting the tone and leading a department and sort of um showing people the way, but it's also really crucially charting the path of the agency itself. Uh so quite often you'll have a chief strategy officer and might have a deputy working underneath them that will be the head of strategy who will be more the internal sort of departmental chief, um, and really the chief strategy officer is to think, um, okay, what is what is our agency? What is our brand about? And that is something that agencies do very badly typically. They don't build their own brands, but if you have a good chief strategy officer, they should help uh with that process of building a brand for the agency.
SPEAKER_00When we're talking about strategy, can you explain that in layman's to someone who isn't familiar in maybe they have an early stage advertising agency, for example, and they only and don't yet have those roles even defined in the business even from a entry-level position.
SPEAKER_01Of course. And and actually it's important to say that you don't always need strategists to do strategy. Strategy is a function, uh, and there have been many great agencies around the world who at various points in history have not had strategists, but they've had people who can do strategy. You know, a lot of the best creative people I've worked with have been incredible strategists because that's you know something that comes naturally to them. So, what strategy is really is making the choices in the first place as to what are what is the business problem, uh, what therefore can we do about it? Is that a communication solution? Or increasingly is it not a communication solution? Because I think you know what you mustn't do is to jump into the answer as an ad, just because we do ads. You know, perhaps the answer is not to advertise but get your product right or your distribution right or do something different with the pricing, or have you thought about doing this completely different thing altogether? And that's increasingly um where a lot of strategists are getting a lot of you know good results. So so you need to do all of that thinking up front before you get into the execution. So it's getting the brief right. And if you get that wrong, obviously you can go off in completely the wrong direction. If in fact, if you get if you get it wrong just by a little bit, you know, then ultimately those differences will multiply and by the end uh you'll be probably in quite a bad place potentially. Um so it's it's really important to not leap into uh solutions and ideas until you've got the brief straight.
SPEAKER_00And so then does is it then really important that much of that brief gets done pre-bringing the client on? Is it part of the client acquisition process? Because correct me if I'm wrong, my perception of Lucky Generals is that you are a creative first agency. And so if you are then working with a client that potentially their problem runs much deeper than just needing better advertisement, um, presumably that is part of what determines whether or not you actually take a client on or not, or do you offer a more holistic solution where you do get involved in distribution and logistics and pricing and all of the strategy behind that?
SPEAKER_01It sort of really depends. Um we so we set up to be a creative company for people on emissions. So the creative company bit was is is speaks to the point you're making, which is not just about advertising, it's all sorts of other creative solutions to business problems for people. Because we we figured out that businesses are all about people, obviously, and we forget that at our peril. I mean, I think it's obvious, but a lot of you know agencies forget that. And we wanted to work with people that wanted to make a difference, that we were on a mission, and so that right from the beginning kind of defines the sort of clients that we were that we're gonna work well with. That had historically been the sort of people that we had worked well with in the past, and it's the sort of people we want to work with in the future. And so I guess what that does right from the beginning is give you a certain pool of people. Now, the what we always say in our first meetings is you don't need to have already nailed the mission. Some people come straight in and can say, I know exactly what I want to do, we've done all this research, we've got this really strong point of view, this is our mission. Uh, can you help us bring it to life? We might then challenge it, we might question it, um, and then we decide whether we agree with it or not. And we're we're very good at sort of politely saying if we don't agree with it. But uh then you get other clients who come in and say, No, we don't. Um we we know we need a mission, we need to have something you know to galvanize the whole organization, but we don't have it yet, and we want you to help us find out what it is. So we we work in both sort of modes. But the important thing is you don't don't jump straight into the idea. We we love that there's a lovely quote, but I think it's usually a tribute to Einstein. I I don't think he actually said it. Like a lot of these things, he sort of it's probably uh credit to him, but it wasn't him. But he said, if you gave me an hour to solve a problem, I'd spend 55 minutes uh defining what the problem is and then five minutes solving it. Um that's probably a bit extreme. I don't know um if we we would ever do something as extreme as that, but I I think you certainly want to get your the problem straight and the this sort of strategy straight first before you begin because it saves you loads of time as well in in the long run.
SPEAKER_00We're gonna get deeper into service delivery for sure. But um you were in this position in the agency, you'd already worked yourself out to that C level position and and then decided you wanted to start your own agency. What's the trigger point that that meant you know this is right for me to go out on my own? And and you actually brought two other team members at the was it the same agency that you were working at at the time?
SPEAKER_01Yeah, so basically I have worked with my two partners, Helen Calcraft and Danny Book Tiller for years, I mean decades. Um Helen, probably about 30 years, and she had uh we started off at the same agency together, and then I went off and did some other stuff, but then she started her own agency. So really Helen had already started this agency called MCBD that was really successful. Um I came on after a year or so, so I wasn't there right at the beginning, but effectively was part of the startup team, and then Danny came on a couple of years after that. So we had already established um this sort of trio um by that stage after a few years we were really running it, and um we sold it um and then we sold it in chunks to a big you know Canadian company, and then there was a little moment at the end where we uh where we had an opportunity to either cash in our last chunk of money um or to roll it in and merge it with another company in that group. So it's slightly complicated, but the the the the sort of summary of it is we decided we already had a startup um which had been successful and we we'd sold, and then we decided to merge it with someone else. And it was a fucking nightmare. I mean it was quite successful still, but it was very uh we didn't like it. It wasn't it wasn't happy making, which is really instructive. So but what it did was absolutely make us realise, oh no, that was a misstep, um, and we we need to do our own thing. Uh you know, if it didn't work because I mean everyone on paper said, you know, all the trade press said this is going to be the best idea. You know, we were the the effectiveness agency of the year. Um this agency called DARE was the digital agency of the decade. So it was kind of putting an advertising agency and a digital agency together, it made loads of sense. Everyone was lovely, there was no sort of people problems. If anything, I think there was maybe almost too many nice people, and we could have been a bit more ruthless on both sides of um, you know, sort of uh defining exactly who the team was. Anyway, for whatever reason, we didn't like it. But uh so many times in business, the thing that feels like misfortune turns out to be good fortune because it made us realise no, let's do this, and that's exactly what we did very quickly afterwards.
SPEAKER_00So when you say you you you sold that in chunks, you you're separating certain can you define that? What do you mean by that?
SPEAKER_01Well, I think we sold, I mean, perhaps we sold um I don't know the exact numbers, but let's say for the sake of it, we sold 50% first to this company. Um and then there was some sort of R and out, and then we said, right, we're gonna sell the next 20%. Um and then it as I say it was within our discretion to just cash in the last 20% or actually use that as part of a different deal to say, no, rather than do that, we'll we'll merge it with this company. So it was it was we can't blame anyone else, it was our own decision. We decided to do it. Um but it was so instructive because it what it what it means is you you gotta you know you first of all it gave us a big sort of learning that mergers, you know, there's a reason that most mergers don't work. I mean, virtually all mergers um fail, so that's that's kind of quite a good watch out. Uh and it also it sort of taught us that that big corporate world isn't necessarily for us, and also that we wanted to build something completely new. That was the big learning. We went, let's build something completely new of our own rather than smoosh two admittedly very good things together. Uh and by the way, some people are good at that, and you know, um, but it just wasn't right for us.
SPEAKER_00So then coming from that and deciding that you wanted to start a new brand, how did Lucky Generals become formed? Where did that name come from? What was the original idea of that?
SPEAKER_01Do you know the name itself came late in the day? That that was kind of one of these weird things. We faffed around and had lots of absolutely terrible names, which I'm embarrassed to uh I'd be embarrassed to sort of dredge up now. But um, but and we eventually landed on Lucky Generals um late in the day. We liked the collective nature of it. We're all in this together, you know. We really felt that because as I say, we'd had this bad experience, um, and we really wanted to build a you know team of people that you know felt like this was a little gang, a little group of people, and then luck, you need luck in business. Nobody talks about that, but we we liked the sort of slightly mischievous nature of that and a little sparkle. Um it's a Napoleon quote. Um, somebody asked him, What do you look for in your generals? and he sort of said, Um, I just bring me your lucky generals. In other words, people've got a track record. So there was also a kind of an underlying um confidence again about people who can go into battle and uh you know win a war for their um clients. Uh so we liked a little bit of that as well. It's been one of the, you know, it's probably the best decision we ever made was the name. Um but I can't pretend there was huge amounts of thought put into it at the time. It's it's turned out turned out to be that. And do you know that is a good thing about names, names reveal themselves afterwards. You can have the most amazing name in theory, but if you don't do good work and if your company doesn't live up to it, then people will ultimately think that's a bad name. You know, um, and and and this the the opposite is also true. It's like your kids, if you if you once you look at your kids and once you know that they have that name, you can't imagine them being called anything else, but they you know they sort of grow into a name. You know, go Google's a rubbish name. Um Ask Jeeves is a much better name, really. But you know, which one one MySpace is a better name than Facebook, you know. So really names are our our understanding of why people will now all will say that Lucky Dem is a great name, but if we'd done terrible work and been a horrible place to work, then then nobody would be saying that.
SPEAKER_00Something that's increasingly harder is picking good names. It's just a minefield, everybody's got everybody all that thing. We have to invent words now in order to do that.
SPEAKER_01Oh yeah, that's that's true. The domain, you know, and so yeah, my thing would be yes, of course, it is in some ways very important, but don't let it paralyze you. That that is the thing. You ultimately the name is gonna be the icing on the cake of a great idea, and that if that idea is great, then everyone will think the name is great. Um, but it's not gonna save you an amazing, clever name is not gonna save you if the idea is not good.
SPEAKER_00What does early stage client acquisition look like when you just split off from the the merger?
SPEAKER_01It was interesting because we uh we d deliberately decided to start with no clients, uh, which is kind of unheard of in the ad industry. It you usually begin with a big founding client to sort of bankroll you. And we deliberately didn't want to do that because of this sort of experience with this desire to start with a blank sheet of paper and like really do it properly. Um now that made it a little bit scarier um because we didn't have that, you know, we couldn't pay ourselves any money for the first few months. Um but that in itself then became a driving force because it makes you hungry, you know. It means that you're not starting with the comfort of knowing that everything's already been paid for. You have to hit the ground running. So that's what we did. And what you'll find is that you're you're so defined by your first couple of clients, and and so it's incredibly important to choose. I mean, that is the truth of startup throughout the stage of uh an agency's life, but in particular right at the beginning, because you're gonna be you're gonna be marked and analyzed or sort of associated with you know the first couple of people you hang around with. And so you have to resist the temptation to just go for the money. I mean, again, that's a sort of an ongoing thing, but I think it's particularly true at the beginning. We were offered a founding client that a huge sum of money without a pitch for a financial services company. Um and we we met them because we we will meet most people for a coffee, um, just to, you know, because perhaps we don't like the sound of them, but they might be the brief might be precisely to change and do something completely different. So we will we will uh have open minds about most things. We met this um company, they were nice people, but the business wasn't nice. We didn't feel it was ethical, it was slightly exploitative financial sort of service, and and so we turned it down. It was like being one of those game shows where the you know they're they're more or less holding a big bag of money, or the they're showing you the speedboat, kind of saying, Yeah, you could have won this. This is what you could have won. And we are starting saying no. But we didn't regret it once, you know. We walked away from that building. I remember all of us looking at each other and saying, We're not doing that, are we? Nah. And and never, ever, ever, ever regretting that. Whereas, you know, a lot of people in our industry would have taken the money in and that would have been a very different agency trajectory.
SPEAKER_00So, your your first client, those first meetings that you're securing, were they coming inbound from PR that you created around the brand the new agency brand? Or were you outbounding to get those meetings?
SPEAKER_01We have never really done a lot of outbound. Um, and I don't say that in a smug way. I think I think a big a big need for you running an agency is to make sure you're getting inbound by by using PR. I mean, we're supposed to be in the communications industry. It always amazes me how bad agencies are at building their own brands and communicating and using PR. And so we we've always been pretty good at that. And we already had a good reputation, and so because we were starting with no clients, we knew we had to get out of there, make a big noise, say we were, you know, what we were all about, uh and then this then we started getting calls coming in. But you know, it took a while, and it was a it was a slightly nerve-wracking. We always joke that we we used to go out and have lunch, but you know, we didn't really know how we were paying for these lunches. Uh, we'd choose cushions, you know, we'd be doing all these sort of things, you know, not really working for the first couple of months, and and the phone would uh very occasionally ring. In fact, there was a there was a company called Um people kept getting the wrong number for us, so we kept on getting phone calls. And first of all, we didn't know where the landline was, because obviously even by that stage it was 2013, nobody used the landline. So we were thinking, hell, where's the landline? We're looking around for it. And then it would be a call for a company called Hard to Find Wines, which is like such an amazing, beautiful irony. This very elusive wine company that had the same number as us or similar number. And so we were always kind of saying, No, it's not hard to find wines, and you know, but if you want any advertising, you can have it. Yeah, nice, nice.
SPEAKER_00But you are struggling hard to find them. Yeah, yeah. You you mentioned agencies are like famously bad at advertising themselves. I'm interested, from a tactical perspective, uh, what are let's say the three most effective strategies that you guys use in order to get yourself out there in the world?
SPEAKER_01I mean, PR uh f well, first of all, I should say do great work. That is that's the best um that's the best strategy because. Because, you know, if if we create a great campaign for Yorkshire T, let's say, that millions of people see, you're much more likely to see that than something that we have, you know, um written in the trade press. So having said that though, uh, that's not enough. And this is the mistake that agencies make. Agencies think we'll let the work speak to itself and everyone will beat a path to our door, but they just won't, because there's lots of good agencies. I mean, London in particular, but Britain generally is massively over subscribed in terms of two, there's too many agencies. They all do pretty good work on a good, you know, on a any given day. And so if you're relying on a client who again are busier than ever these days to remember who does what and and know, oh yeah, that's the one they're looking at. Yeah, that is not going to happen. That is highly unlikely. So you do have to do your own stuff. So, yes, PR and all those things, the best thing we ever did was write a book. And this is where again we took it, we we applied our own thinking to our own problem and thought, okay, if our challenge is how do we um raise awareness for lucky generals? And this was in COVID, so there was a specific urgency um lockdown that just happened, and we were all thinking, How the hell are we going to run a business? You know, we can't even really have new business meetings now. So, how do we get people coming to our door? And so we uh we wrote a book called Go Luck Yourself, uh, which is sort of a kind of fun um but but actually serious point behind it about how you harness luck and you know uh maximise your chances of success in business. Uh and that that was a massive success story for us, not least because all of a sudden the dynamic completely flips because people are paying for your cred. I mean, imagine that rather rather than you chasing people down and sending people LinkedIn messages, that's people going to Amazon or Waterstones and buying your book and then asking you, can you come and do a talk about it? So that was that was really um that was really good, and then we gave all the money from that to uh a cause that we really believed in, which is um helping working class kids get a lucky break into the industry. So there was a there was a lovely sort of circular aspect to it as well, that a book about luck that brings luck to other people and then also brought a lot of luck to lucky generals. What's the general premise of the book? So the book is that the the premise is that nobody talks about luck. I mean, in fact, it's an insult in Western society. And I talk about the reasons for that, you know, is it's the Protestant work ethic and this belief that if I said to you you're really lucky, you'd probably think that's a bit cheeky, you know, because it sounds like I'm saying you're not talented and hard working. But actually, they're not opposites. They are things, yes, you have to be talented, obviously, yes, you have to be hardworking, but after a certain point you need some luck. And actually, just you know, the the old sort of um sort of capitalist person work ethic answer that that you must just spend longer at your desk working on a problem is probably less likely to get you uh, you know, to a great interest and creative solution. You're more likely to go off and you know, have a walk in the park or go to an art gallery or go to a gig and be inspired by other stuff in life. And so the book is really about how do you how do you maximize those odds. And there's there's actually quite a lot of science behind luck because it's really it's just about um uh you know chances, possibilities. You know, it's it's um you go back to your maths class, if you can remember that, back at school when you were taught about probabilities. There are certain things you can do that greatly increase your chances of success, whether you're creating advertising or whether you're running a business. Um and and if you if you don't accept them, if you think there's no such thing as luck, then you can't change them. Whereas it like a lot of things in life, if you appreciate them and are conscious of them, then you you can more consciously try and sort of game the system in your favour. What's the simplest way that somebody can engineer more luck in their life? Well, I mean, one way I I would say just appreciate what you got. We're rubbish at doing this. We know that and that is true in life. There's lots of science that show that if you take a moment in your day to appreciate all the good things in your life or one good thing in your life, then you're more likely to succeed because it just makes you think about okay, I've achieved that or that's happened to me, or this person has been kind to me, and there's a lot of good knock-on effects that come from that. Um I would say agencies and brands need to do that because a lot of the time the answer is sitting right under their nose. One of the big things that we have done a lot of the times is to help companies see that an old asset, a historic asset, a great line from the past, is an amazing thing that they are so lucky to have and they're not maybe appreciating it. Like if your Iron Brew, the line made in Scotland from Garders, that that is absolute gold dust. If you've got a line like that that people remember for decades, and yes, you have to reinterpret it, but you know, you need to appreciate how lucky you are to have that. And so a lot of our work um uh has has been helping clients kind of see the answer that is obvious perhaps to an outsider, but they're so familiar with that they don't appreciate it. So appreciating what you got would be one of the easiest ones. I like that.
SPEAKER_00Just going back into the the the early stages of the agency again. You I would I would like to unpack the partnerships that you had with the your founders that you still have now. And how or you define a great partnership between founders? I think it's something I speak to a lot of early stage agency founders, and there's always a debate of do I keep this thing for myself, do I bring somebody else in, should I join forces, and I'm keen on your general philosophy around that.
SPEAKER_01I think partnership is I mean, certainly in our world, but I I suspect in most entrepreneurial situations is incredibly helpful because one person doesn't have every skill set. And so if you have, you know, first of all, there's just a basic um mixture of skills, which that brings, you know, you have complementary abilities, and we very much do. We in our world it's quite often, and this is how we've um done it, you know, someone like me, the strategist, um, someone from more business, you know, account handling perspective, Helen Calcraft, and then Creative Dector, um, Dan Boot Taylor. So we we have very three different disciplines. Of course, there's an overlap, and we all have opinions on you know each other's worlds, but we we're also very respectful of our own individual sort of crafts, if you like. Um so there's a skill thing, then there's a sort of a personality thing. We're all three very different people. Um, and then there's a support thing, you know. Um you go through difficult times as a startup, you will hit blocks, you will have problems. How do you navigate out of those? It's it's useful to have multiple perspectives and opinions. Um, and then there's a lovely sort of galvanizing thing right at the end as well as well. You know, if you when you have to make a decision, and so much of being an entrepreneur is just making the decision, whether it's right or wrong, you just have to decide and move on. And I think there's something about having three of you that forces you to, okay, we're gonna do this now. Whereas if you're left with a decision on your own, you might still, you know, not have a full stop to the decision. You might keep on mulling it, and you don't have anyone that say, Come on, mate, let's just do this now. We're gonna, you know, uh get on with it.
SPEAKER_00On the flip side today, you make decisions that haven't had the entirety considered and yeah, yeah, that yeah, that's right.
SPEAKER_01So I I I it's been an absolutely it has really been the success story of our agency, and then we've tried to um go the extra step, which again a lot of agencies don't do, is to try and foster that same sort of spirit throughout the rest of the agency. Because what we try and do is not just have a structure that is incredibly hierarchy where I've got lots of people reporting it to me. We like to create other people, have other people creating their own little trios or little groups and gangs within the agency when they're working on an account, you know, and you sort it out yourself, don't come running running to mum or dad, you know. Um yes, we're there with advice if you need it, and some accounts will need more advice than others, but it's great, it's the loveliest thing when we get you know three or four or five young people who have sort of thrashed out a problem themselves and then maybe come to us with a hypothesis and can say, we think it's this, and yes, then we can um give them you know a steer. But it's it's much nicer if they've got to a place together because that's going to teach them so much.
SPEAKER_00So four years after launching, you sold majority share to Omnicon's TBWA. Why did you do that? Because it sounds like you had a lot of early success. So what triggered you to make that decision?
SPEAKER_01Um certain factors. One is you you to to grow um you you ultimately need some extra source of funding. And um in our case, we we knew we wanted to launch into the States, so that was that was a particularly um you know demanding uh move because it's it's it's uh incredibly expensive market. I mean the rewards are high, but also the costs uh of getting started are high. Um so there's there was that. Uh we also frankly had a personal issue because Helen uh got diagnosed with cancer um for the second time, breast cancer. And so that was something we had known about when we started the business that she'd had it before, but obviously we didn't know that she was gonna have it again. Obviously, that then takes precedence over everything. I mean, that was the only thing we were worried about, and it has then had some knock-on effects because that perfectly formed trio, you know, Helen was off, although she was, you know, crazily phoning in, you know, left, right, and centre quite a lot. Um uh, but was also you know, we we really missed her obviously mostly as a person, but just her incredible skills that you know Danny and I don't have, so we were sort of left on our own a bit there, and all collectively, then you have to make this decision about you and your families as to okay, is it it's probably quite um useful to to sell a stake, not the whole uh agency, but to um you know look after our families and make sure that that you know we don't know what's going to happen here, god forbid, it could have been you know, um, you know, a very different ending sort of thing. So at that stage we thought, let's be sensible here, safeguard our families' futures. Um we're not in a desperate state to um to sell, and we said no to lots of people and kept on saying no, including to Omnicom and TWA, and eventually we you know, because we were in such a strong position, we got a really good um price for um uh you know what could have been a potentially quite difficult situation. And you know, that that that turned out to be a really good move for us, and Helen thankfully is is much better now.
SPEAKER_00Did that did it invite corporate complexity into the business? Did a lot change in the day-to-day when that happened?
SPEAKER_01Do you know the thing that attracted to us was that um that that they stayed out of the business? If you go back to the you know, how did we start? And as I say, the fact that we had not enjoyed the merger, there was a conversation about whether we would merge with uh TBWA and we we said we wouldn't because of that. Um we weren't in the mood for that, and and so we said no, and and then they went away. And then they came back and they said, well, actually, if you help us find a management team for TBWA, um, then you don't need to merge with them. So it was a slightly odd responsibility that we'd find a management team for them. But that's that was the deal that we did that we would um that we would uh do our own thing and that they would leave us alone and why would they buy us only to change us? And that that was the sort of uh you know the the thing that attracted us to them.
SPEAKER_00So that's something that you look back at as completely the right call to make in the business at that time?
SPEAKER_01Yeah, I mean I think yes, um you don't I think you can't regret these things. You have to make you make the decision and you have to remember what was going on back, you know, back then, and you know, uh there have been occasions on the road where you know little little glitches happen and and you you'll you know all all entrepreneurs I think will have wistful thoughts back to their early days and kind of think the days when they were completely free. But then they'll forget that some of the the good things that they come out of the decisions that they've made and you can't we're we're very much I think this is a good thing about again about having a three is you we encourage each other to look forward and not to look back ever, you know, about wistfully, oh if only we'd done this or if only we'd done that. You know, we made a decision, we all agreed in it. If anyone wanted to not agree with that, we should have said there at the time and we've made that decision to move on. So yeah. Nice.
SPEAKER_00And you've since scaled to over 150 team members now?
SPEAKER_01I think it's about something like that. Yeah, if you include New York, yeah.
SPEAKER_00Yeah. What's some of your biggest lessons on scaling teams so quickly?
SPEAKER_01Lesson number one is don't scale for the sake of it. You know, this is not a race to get big. I mean, some people do that, but we we've never been interested in being big for the sake of it. Um so if size came, it was by a happy accident rather than, you know, it it was in pursuit of us doing some good work rather than because we want to be big. Uh so that the number one thing, don't chase the money, kind of is related to that. Do great work and the money will come. And then it's be careful not to have any ghettos. That's always been a big um thing that agencies have got to um look out for. In other words, if you get a one or two big accounts, they can dominate the agency. And and while they're superficially attractive, it can feel great to have a really big, you know, meaty set of corporate client. Then if you become too beholden to them too, if they're too big a percentage of your revenue and you're only servicing them, that can change the culture of the place, both financially because you're sort of beholden to them and worried about you know losing them. Um but also it can culturally you can start people can start to feel like, well, I only work on this account and I'm I'm now kind of not working at Lucky Journals, I'm working on something else, sort of thing. So we've we've always kind of made sure that people work on different accounts and and we we're very keen not to have ghettos. And you know, when you've got when you're 100, we're we've only become 150 very recently, you know, until very recently would be about 80 or so people. Um and it's pretty easy to avoid ghettos in that sort of um in that kind of size. But when you get bigger, it it it that does become a real challenge.
SPEAKER_00How does org structure look in the company? So does the does the pod model deteriorate at at your level of scale or or do you operate in pods? Like what does it look like inside the company?
SPEAKER_01In terms of sort of um sort of groups of people. Yeah, yeah. Yeah, we sort of mix people up really. We we as I say we like to try not to have people only working with the same people, because that doesn't it's two things. It doesn't help the individuals um and it doesn't help the clients either. Sometimes clients will say to us, oh, but we'd we love this person, we'd love them 100%. And we will very politely say, We know you love them 100%, we love them 100% too, but you you're not doing them any favors by insisting that you have all of them, and actually you're not doing yourself any favors because one of the great things about an agency is when the person who works on your account 70% of the time uses that other 30% of the time to bring something fresh. You you know you might be working on um a big uh car brand and someone else, and that that person says, Oh, well, have you thought about you know um the drinks market? You know, uh and there might be a really interesting sort of uh juxtaposition from another part of the world that that person will bring in. So we we sort of strongly feel and argue with our clients that we should we should we shouldn't have mixed teams and and that will bring freshness to their thinking as well as our to our people.
SPEAKER_00Logistically, how does how does that work? How are you do you you built like an internal project management system for that? Do you use external systems?
SPEAKER_01We have do you know what? We have project management uh systems and then good old-fashioned um uh you know sort of human beings. I I listened to Lucy Jameson on on this, maybe from last year, was it? Or and I thought I 100% agreed with you can't fully automate that. Automation has become quite a useful part of this, you know, who's available when and all the rest of it. But ultimately, there are so many personal dynamics whereby you're you know that that person gets on with this person, or oh that person's quite junior, so maybe they need someone who's a bit more senior. There's so many intangible bits in getting a team to work properly. But as I say, that is, I think, been the whole success of our agency is understanding the power of internal chemistry, starting with the three of us, but then replicating that through the rest of the agency.
SPEAKER_00So it's quite fluid then when you sign up a new account in the decision-making process of who works on that account and and so and it's not it's not rigid or there's no algorithm behind it per se.
SPEAKER_01It's no, not really. I mean, um no, we use common sense, we have to understand what the nature of the business problem is and what the clients are like, who are they gonna get on with? You know, again, that's stuff that a machine can't easily judge. You know, we might realise that this person is going to respond better to this sort of management style, or um yeah, you might have discovered something through the pitch, you might start a pitch process with and then realize, or or you might be told the client might kind of say, actually, I love everything about it, but that person then I'm not quite sure about. And what what we've also um learned from the early days is as a threesome, uh, the three of us, is that you shouldn't take it personally if if a client doesn't you know like you. We always sort of joke, if they say that they they don't like the the Scottish guy, which I don't know why we always use that as the exam. And I I keep on saying that Helen Dunny, that is a hypothetical Scottish guy, isn't it? But and it's a love, but they that is always, yeah, if they say they don't like the Scottish guy, don't put the Scottish guy. You know, and sometimes you have to sort of fight against that because you can't you might have a good reason for why so we don't let clients dictate who's on what, but obviously it's common sense if they express a strong feeling about a person um to take that into account and not just ignore it.
SPEAKER_00Is there then a a an account lead to someone who's uh the the manager of that specific account as well as the the main point of contact and they delegate across the team, or is is everybody very proactively engaged in interaction with the client?
SPEAKER_01Sort of depends. I mean again that that sort of three that triangle of a strategist, a business director of some level, you know, that there's various sorts, um, and then a creative leader. Um and then depending on the size of the account, you know, they they might really be quite sort of autonomous. And we again we want people to be autonomous, um especially for smaller clients where it's sort of overbearing of us to kind of be poking our nose in, and probably not economical, um, and we should you know um allow them to do the thing, um with a bit of oversight from us. And then obviously the bigger clients where it's kind of more of the founders are you know involved or more of the management team. We we kind of tend to have each account will have at least one founder with some sort of nominal involvement. You know, even if we're not really involved in the day-to-day, we like to know the people, we like to know the senior um clients, and sometimes and often they really like it because they like to know that the client the founders are still involved. Uh and sometimes they can use us with their own um you know chief execs or you know their senior people because it's something that's quite helpful to um to sort of wheel out a founder in in in sort of defense of an idea. Nice.
SPEAKER_00So you you of course expanded into a New York office. Uh what's your opinion on physical presence and whether or not it's still a necessity in the modern agency world?
SPEAKER_01I think it is to some degree. I mean, obviously we're and we're very um open, I would say, on the working from home aspects of things. You know, we we try to be very supportive of people um working flexibly, but ultimately there comes a point where you've got to be able to come together with people, and ideas are often best discussed or generated when you're in the same room together. So we we do think that is really important. Um and for that reason we we did set up in New York physically. We had already been doing a lot of work in New York, so it was kind of interesting, like as I said at the beginning, we we were already doing Super Bowl ads from Exworth Market, which seemed a bit crazy, but we were doing a really good job of it. Um and then ultimately we we won a cruise line. Uh and the funny thing was what we so we won a cruise line, we and on the back of that, they were based in Miami, they're called celebrity cruises, and we said, okay, this is probably now time where we need an office in on the east coast. Uh and we actually chose New York rather than Miami because again, Miami's an amazing market, but we didn't want to be s exclusively beholden to that that cruise climb. Now, the only flaw in that little plan was that was in I want to say the back end of 2019. Um and then a couple of months later, this thing called COVID happened. And so our we'd already shelled out in a nice big fancy physical space in New York with a cruise line as our founding client. So you can imagine that was slightly nerve-wracking. You know, very expensive uh moment in time. Uh and also our model where we were going to go and we the idea was that we would fly back and forth or go and help, you know, the this relatively young team sort of get up and running didn't happen, obviously, because we um we we couldn't do that. So that that was a very, very, very trying time for a couple of years. But again, you out of these kind of tough moments, you hang on in there. You don't, you know, it would have been easy to just cash in our chips, but you we really believed that New York was ready for that kind of brand. Um, we've made we've adjusted the team, we've got an amazing team there now. I think you have to adjust to have the right level of American versus um you know British people, that's always a discussion point. Um you maybe want a little bit of your DNA so that there's a sort of a connective tissue with the mothership, if you like, but then you need to really have homegrown talent, I think, to sort of be talking to American marketers. So we had a bit of an adjustment period, and that that's been so brilliant to watch how that is from that really kind of crazily rocky start, has now become really successful in in New York.
SPEAKER_00What do you think? Defines the the different the core differences between English marketers and American marketers?
SPEAKER_01Ooh, um well I worked in the States for a couple of years in San Francisco, it was quite a long time ago, but I think I think there's there is a more directness. There's probably a slightly more commercial it's interesting, there's there's a sort of a commercial salesy culture in the States. Um I don't know if there's always such a strong effectiveness culture, weirdly enough. There's kind of a slightly more um slightly more uh hard-nosed sort of sales approach sometimes, you know, just tell me how much extra money is this making in a kind of a short-term sense, um, rather than the kind of I feel like the effectiveness culture that people like Mart Ritson or Les Binet have kind of created over here is perhaps not quite as well entrenched in marketing culture in the States. But you really my big understanding of the States is it's such an enormous market that to sort of generalise out about it is is really difficult because of course they do the best, I think they do the best advertising, the best marketing, the best brand building in the world, and also you know, some really bad stuff as well. It's like they do the best literature, the best films, and also the the worst literature and the worst films, the best and worst of everything, because it's that incredible sort of uh variety, which is why we all love it.
SPEAKER_00Can you define effectiveness culture for the listeners?
SPEAKER_01So effectiveness culture is having uh this might sound like state in the bleed and obvious, um, but it's really important, is having a really deep-rooted belief in and care for what uh and whether your work is actually working, you know, your ad with this let's say advertising, it's not always advertising, but is this advertising actually making a difference in the real world? And a lot of the time agencies unfortunately pay lip service to that, you know. They they might say, Oh, well, lots of people noticed it or got you know a lot of uh social media posts and things like that, which are fine, they're good to know about, but has it actually really commercially made a difference? And then but it's actually a lot of the time it's quite it's it's more complicated, which is why I was sort of saying that some American marketers maybe don't have the sophistication, but it's more complicated than just saying, Oh, well, sales went up or sales didn't go up, because in a lot of markets it's it's about market share and it's about slightly longer-term effects. You know, if I if I advertise a car brand today, you're not going to run out and buy a car tomorrow. But over time, through consistent marketing, you're building a brand, and the the real power of brands is they generate vastly greater profits than just short-term um sales um techniques. There are there's something that's a little bit harder to pull out because they happen over a long period of time. So it's really trying to instill in everyone the kind of culture that measurement is very important, understanding if things work are very important, but let's have a degree of sophistication, let's not everyone panic if we if we don't sell anything the day after the campaign begins. You have to understand these things in the round.
SPEAKER_00So then moving from effectiveness to creativity, which is obviously something that's really important to you guys, how do you make sure you maintain a really strong creative culture in a really fastly growing company?
SPEAKER_01I think it's about having uh a sense of playfulness, funnily enough. I think but playfulness is at the heart of creativity because if you're playing and you're not scared of making mistakes and you're you're enjoying yourself and you're not worried about your job, um, then I think you're much more likely to come up with more interesting, more unusual ideas than if you're terrified for your job and sort of under the caution under a lot of stress. And and again, a lot of agencies don't work their people that way. They you know put people under the caution, something's driven by their clients, and then you know, force them to come up with ideas quickly and with the with the sort of um caveat that they should be sort of you know uh instantly viable and sort of conventional. And that that kind of that pushes people towards thinking and worrying and overthinking about the work and coming up with the same stuff as everyone else has done. Um so you've got to liberate people and sort of make people, you know, realize that you're gonna be rewarded for trying to do cool, interesting, different stuff. Crucially, that works. But but that that is what does work these days. Doing something average isn't is actually the biggest risk of all. If you do something boring and average and um nondescript, that is a surefire way to waste all your clients' money. So you've got to you've got to do something that's distinctive and original, fresh, um, and still effective.
SPEAKER_00How has AI impacted creativity inside of the business?
SPEAKER_01AI is as um AI is a is a very useful tool to help you sort of manage some of the administration and and speed up the way that you can get to good ideas. So um uh from my my um place, I I'll for my sort of division if you like, doing a competitive review, having a having a look at who does what in this marketplace is like a standard sort of strategic or account handling task. Um that that can now happen instantly, you know, and it still needs analysis as to who's doing what and why they're doing it, and there's a sort of a human touch to it. But there's a lot of dog's body work. Research is a classic thing where AI is speeding things up massively and reducing costs. So that's fantastic. It also helps you get quicker sometimes to expressions of ideas. So if you're trying to bring something to life, you know, one of the reasons that really out there great ideas fail is that sometimes it can be hard for clients to imagine them. Um and we'd have to spend tons of money to bring them to life. Um so you're left kind of saying, well, just imagine. And now you can actually obviously create with incredible degree of sort of realism. It might not be perfect and it's not enough to go on screen or um to go out in the real world, but you can get really far down the line, and that that's potentially fantastically liberating because it sort of helps clients see, oh, okay, it could look like that. Now I can see it. So I think it's through the administration, it's the speeding up, the prototyping, and yeah, there's a whole bunch of backroom stuff as well. Where it doesn't uh help you is w getting to the big ideas in the first place. That that is our and that is going to be the future of the industry. Basically the people who are gonna succeed, I think, are, and certainly this is what we would where we would see our future, is in the creation of those big platform ideas that only a human being can really come up with. Um, and then yes, the algorithms and machines will take over and do all the other stuff around it, um, but there's gonna be a top level of of very high-level creative stuff that an algorithm will never manage.
SPEAKER_00Do you think it will put the spotlight on great creative thinkers more than ever because the majority of the market is leaning too heavily and blending into the masses somewhat? I hope so.
SPEAKER_01I mean the big thing is that if if you if you find that some of your work is gonna is being taken over by AI, it probably suggests that your work isn't creative enough in the first place. You know, that there is huge amounts of just stuff out there, millions of absolutely I mean literally millions of of absolutely missable communications. Um and if that's what you're doing, then I I would be very worried because you will never do that more efficiently than uh than an algorithm. That that is absolutely toast. That's not going to be a business anymore. Um so you've got to elevate, and and I think that's why it's interesting. AI should not be this thing that we're all doom and gloomy about. There are some, I think there's some very big ethical risks about copyright, and there's some social risks about you know what sort of economy we're creating where um where where you know AI is in control and all that kind of sort of stuff. But the but but but in terms of our creative the creative business, we should see this as an amazing kick up the bum to kind of be more creative and use AI to help us rather than I don't want to do all that stuff, that boring stuff down there. I'd I'd be much happier if I could spend my whole life just doing big ideas rather than all the crap around it.
SPEAKER_00Well, talking of big ideas and looking at some of the projects and campaigns that you've worked on, which one stands out as your personal favourite?
SPEAKER_01Oh god, that's like choosing your children now. Um that is that is difficult. Who have I not talked about? Uh I'll I well I'll talk about Virgin Atlantic. I've always adored Virgin Atlantic. I worked on it in a previous life, maybe about 30 years ago, um, with a great agency called Rainy Kelly, Campbell Rolfe, and we did amazing work for them. I absolutely loved it. Over the years I've worked on Virgin uh Atlantic, Virgin Holidays, Virgin Trains, Virgin Money, and there might be a couple of others. And now we're back to working with Virgin uh Atlantic and holidays again. So it's funny how these things come around. And what so there must be something that draws me to that brand, and maybe it draws that brand to you know me and my team. It's I think it's about that um iconoclastic, Branson-esque um ambition and fearlessness. I mean, he had that great phrase, screw it, let's do it. You know, he's the most buccaneering entrepreneurial. He's every entrepreneur's favourite entrepreneur, isn't he? I mean, that's I'm sure what every small business would say they admire Branson the most. And and so with Virgin Atlantic, I I was really proud that we were able to help them in their moment of need, which was during lockdown, when they'd already had quite a few business challenges previously, so they had financial problems, they'd not been doing well. And then, of course, lockdown came, and it really looked like they might have to file for bankruptcy, frankly, that to lay off all the people. And so we were briefed. Um, I think the client wouldn't mind me saying this, with a sort of a more or less a Hail Mary pass of okay, this has got to absolutely very quickly get us back into the sky with uh, you know, with huge confidence and enthusiasm, get everyone back in, you know, um flying with us, uh including uh our people, because they'd have to lay everybody off, you know, as all the airlines had to do. And there was then going to be a massive scramble to get people, you know, air crews back up into the sky. And they they were, you know, there was morale issues and who were they gonna fly with and so on. And so it was a huge, big this was so much bigger than advertising. We didn't present any advertising in the pitch at all. But the pitch really sort of um centered round, it was only four words in the end, but I think there were four um devastatingly effective words, um, which was see the world differently. See the world differently. See the world differently, worked brilliantly as a sort of a reminder of what Virgin have always done. You know, that that has been Branson's great skill to to look at the world in a different way. Um, particularly, obviously, with Atlantic, you know, you you when you go on holiday, you see the world differently. And now, of course, as we were coming out of lockdown, it was a kind of call for us to all see the world differently. We we'd all had our worlds turned upside down. So it was it was a line that, although there was only four words in it, it was incredibly flexible and and and most of all, perhaps it worked brilliantly with their people. You know, it galvanized everyone to think, okay, when I come into work for Virgin Atlantic, I am going to be seeing the world differently and doing different stuff, and that is that is my test in the morning. Am I seeing the world differently? So it that has been a fantastically powerful um form of words. As I say, I don't think an algorithm would have generated, and has has been used right throughout the journey, whether it's in the the way that uniforms are handled, the HR policies that you know on flights, and um it's a constant reference point for the business. So that that to me is so satisfying for a brand I've got a massive affection for. Um I like to think we've played our part there.
SPEAKER_00So when working on that and coming up with that tagline there, does that how far into the process does that come in? Is that like the big pillar idea that that that the whole project starts with? So you do the strategy piece, diagnose the problem, come up with a big idea for how you can reposition the brand, and then everything else is downstream from their advertisements and so on and so forth? Is that a fair assessment?
SPEAKER_01Yes, what we what we try and do is um and other agencies are different, but we we try to be quickly get to multiple potential ways in with different strategic aspects to them, um, and then try and get clarity and ideally we'd boil it down to one direction and one ideally one line. There's always a big debate about you know how much choice you should give clients, and um we we don't mind having a multiplicity in the early stages, you know, because it's it's it'd be sort of arrogant for us to kind of say, yeah, we can just ace it and come up with the idea you know straight away. You need to have a discussion, and often that discussion you learn a lot from the things that a client tells you would not be right for various reasons that you wouldn't have even considered. How would you know that that wouldn't work in this market or for that reason sort of thing? Um so that is incredibly helpful, but ultimately we do like to do a final meeting where having considered everything, we come to a point of view. Um agencies like to hedge the bets. I we have found, I mean, A, it's not in our nature, and B, it I don't think it works because it's not confident. I feel like you know, after a couple of months or whatever it is of a pitch, you need to have learned enough to have made your mind up and to make a decision for better or worse. And then that will give you much more authority and confidence when you go to the pitch, versus saying, well, you could do a bit of that, or you could do this, or you could be this over there. I I feel that the client would look at you at that stage and go, well, that's what I'm hiring you, surely you tell tell me which one you know um you should be going for. You should you should have a point of view on this by now. Um so that's that's how we like to do it, for better or worse. And then if you don't if you don't get it, then that's fine, but you've at least had an opinion. Um, it would cause you to say no to a brand. Oh, all sorts of things. Um and again, I don't mean that in a sort of uh haughty or sort of um uh arrogant way. Um a lot of the time we say no to brands partly because we think we would not be good for them. We're saving them the trouble of working with us because they they wouldn't like us. So we um we do say no to a lot of business. It's it's that that that point I said at the beginning about being a creative company for people on a mission. A lot of clients don't really feel they're on a mission, they just want to keep sales ticking along. So anything incremental um where the client says, uh, I just want uh an easy life, I don't want to really make a big difference in the world, I think. That that would put us off. Obviously, personal things where if someone was unpleasant, aggressive, uh, felt like they were not going to be a good person to work with. We we like fun people. We we think this industry should be fun, um, and at its best it is, and all our best relations with clients have been quite a good laugh, you know, even when we've been talking about very serious things. And that is not true of every agency. A lot of agencies are very serious cultures, in particular, right now. So we we want them to be fun, nice people to work with. Um, we want them to demand their our best, you know, um, then that'll make us work harder for them. Um uh obviously anything ethical, like it was in a sector where which was which we didn't agree with. Um yeah, I I I feel like you these are big decisions and they make a big impact on people's lives. We've all worked on brands where we thought, God, this is a nightmare, it's miserable, and they don't appreciate us, and um we don't want to put ourselves or our people through any of that. So we'd rather call it quits at the beginning. And you know, thankfully we've got a very good track record of doing that, and it you get a spidey sense, I think. That that's the trick. We we've we try and call it very early and and then it becomes self-fulfilling because it sort of attracts our work attracts other clients that are probably like-minded. So we don't we've never really had a I can't think of a situation where we've ended up working with someone and then thinking, oh my god, they've now revealed themselves to be sort of monsters, and I wish we'd never done that.
SPEAKER_00So you've never had any accounts that you brought in to Lucky Generals that where things haven't gone to plan?
SPEAKER_01Gone to plan, yeah. I'm sure there'll be God there'll be loads of them. You probably you should um ask my clients, I'm sure they'll they'll have loads of examples of that. But I think not from I can't think of one from a misjudgment of um where you know the the nature of the client um and actually again I I come back to if that ever happens, don't blame the client. That's your fault for you you decided to get into bed with them. So um you should have spotted that earlier. Yeah I I mean a good example I'd say by the way is chemistry meetings. So this is a big thing in our industry where you have a an initial meeting to and as the name suggests, chemistry is to see do we just get on well together. Um you you might discuss the the problem, but it's it's slightly more supposed to be about the personalities and the people. But within that, there's an implicit a lot of agencies take that as we're trying to impress you with our chemistry, we're trying to you need to like us. Um but we watch to see whether we like you as well. We've got to like you or want to work with you. And so sometimes we might turn a client down after a chemistry meeting, even if they've put us through and they would like to work with us, because it should work both ways. A chemistry meeting should be both ways, and obviously, again, we're not sort of arrogant or unpleasant about it. We will just sort of say, I just don't think we're gonna be a good fit, and it's lovely that you say that you would like to work with us, but I just think that you're sort of fooling yourselves.
SPEAKER_00Um, so let's call it now. As you've grown, I think it was only a couple years ago, correct me if I'm wrong, that you brought in a new CSO from Drugger 5, which is the role that you were doing in the business. So uh how did that come about and w at what point did you get to to make the decision to bring someone in to effectively replace what you were doing?
SPEAKER_01Yeah. Uh succession is one of the hardest tricks in uh